ࡱ> m RbjbjZcZc6 8 b8 bM$ 66666JJJ8 <J"7'''5555555$ 9;p56'$'''566. 6~4~4~4'665~4'5~4~445N,4560"742<-">52<\>$65''~4'''''550'''"7''''>'''''''''V : Chang Gung University Faculty Work Evaluation Form Current RankSubmission Level ProfessorNameDepartment (Graduate Institute)Reviewers Comments on the Representative Publication StrengthWeakness% Rich Content and Innovative Insights %Conclusions offer academic or practical value %Strong research abilities %Rich in content and rigorously organized Others%Lacks distinctive novelty %Lacks in-depth analysis %Incomplete content%Low academic or practical value %Weak Research Methods and Theoretical Foundation%The paper does not conform to the writing format.%Suspected plagiarism in the work (Please specify the specific facts in the reviewers comments.) OthersRepresentative Publication Rating Criteria and StandardsTotal 40 points (A)Items 1.Research Topic 5 points2. Research Methods and Abilities10 points3.Academic and Practical Contributions 25 pointsScores  Reviewers Comments on Publications from the Last Five Years or from the Previous Rank to the Current Application Rank StrengthWeakness%Rich Content and Innovative Insights %Conclusions offer academic or practical value %Strong research abilities %Rich in content and rigorously organized Others%Lacks distinctive novelty %Lacks in-depth analysis % %Low academic or practical value %Weak Research Methods and Theoretical Foundation %The paper does not conform to the writing format. %Suspected plagiarism in the work (Please specify the specific facts in the reviewers comments.) OthersScores of Overall Academic and Professional Achievement (including the Representative Publication) in the Last Five Years or Since the Previous Rank to the Current Application Rank: 60Scores (B) Review Criteria The applicant should have unique and sustained contributions through significant publications in the academic field. Total Scores (A) + (B) Passing scores are 70 (inclusive) or aboveHighly recommendedRecommendedNot recommended85 ~ 10070 ~ 8469 or belowAccording to your institution's standards for appointment/promotion, does the applicant meet the criteria for recommendation for appointment/promotion to this position/level? %Recommended %Not recommended Reviewer's department and titleReviewer s signatureReview completion dateYear Month DayChang Gung University Faculty Work Evaluation Form Current RankSubmission LevelAssociate ProfessorNameDepartment (Graduate Institute)Reviewers Comments on the Representative Publication StrengthWeakness%Content and Innovative Insights %Conclusions offer academic or practical value %Strong research abilities %Rich in content and rigorously organized Others%Lacks distinctive novelty %Lacks in-depth analysis %Incomplete content%Low academic or practical value %Weak Research Methods and Theoretical Foundation %The paper does not conform to the writing format. %Suspected plagiarism in the work (Please specify the specific facts in the reviewers comments.) OthersRepresentative Publication Rating Criteria and Standards Total 50 points (A)Items 1.Research Topic 10 points2. Research Methods and Abilities 15 points 3. Academic and Practical Contributions 25 pointsScores  Reviewers Comments on Publications from the Last Five Years or from the Previous Rank to the Current Application Rank: StrengthWeakness%Rich Content and Innovative Insights %Conclusions offer academic or practical value %Strong research abilities %Rich in content and rigorously organized Others%Lacks distinctive novelty %Lacks in-depth analysis %Incomplete content %Low academic or practical value %Weak Research Methods and Theoretical Foundation %The paper does not conform to the writing format. %Suspected plagiarism in the work (Please specify the specific facts in the reviewers comments.) OthersScores of Overall Academic and Professional Achievement (including the Representative Publication) in the Last Five Years or Since the Previous Rank to the Current Application Rank: 50Scores (B) Review Criteria The applicant should have unique and sustained contributions through significant publications in the academic field Total Scores (A) + (B)Passing scores are 70 (inclusive) or aboveHighly recommendedRecommendedNot recommended85 ~ 10070 ~ 8469 or belowAccording to your institution's standards for appointment/promotion, does the applicant meet the criteria for recommendation for appointment/promotion to this position/level? %Recommended %Not recommended Reviewer's department and titleReviewer s signatureReview completion date Year Month DayChang Gung University Faculty Work Evaluation Form Current RankSubmission LevelAssistant ProfessorNameDepartment (Graduate Institute)Reviewers Comments on the Representative Publication StrengthWeakness%Rich Content and Innovative Insights %Conclusions offer academic or practical value %Strong research abilities %Rich in content and rigorously organized dfh   2 B ^ v z | ~ ¹§¹¹|pg_T_Th~6hCJPJh~6CJPJhOJPJo(h-hOJPJo(h-CJOJPJo( h~6PJhCJOJPJ h-PJh~6h5PJ h~65PJh~6h~6CJPJh~6hPJhCJOJPJo(h~6h-PJ&jhCJ OJPJUmHnHuh~6h~6PJh-h~6CJ$PJaJ$ f $d$Ifa$gd- 99dx$G$If]9^9 d$Ifgd- 99d$G$If]9^9gd- d$If99d$If]9^9gd-$dpa$ kd$$IfZִnP Bxp#)   X   6  H  0    4 ayt- z | ~ }q[$qd8$G$If]q^a$ $d8$Ifa$fkdV$$If4 ))  04 af4yt- 9x$If^99x$If^9gd- \ R b nbL$qd8$G$If]q^a$ d8$Ifgd- 9r d8$9DH$If d8$Ifvkd$$If40)    04 af4 " Z \ ^ ` * . wnf[PnEPn[h-CJOJPJo(hI7ThCJPJhI7ThI7TCJPJhI7TCJPJhI7TCJPJo(h෩©ymdhNKo5CJPJhNKohNKo5CJPJhOJPJhS5h^LCJKHOJPJh^LCJKHOJPJhCJKHOJPJo(h^LhCJOJPJo(h^Lh^LCJPJhS5h^LCJPJh^LCJPJhI7Th^LCJPJhCJOJPJo(h-CJOJPJo(h^LCJPJo(%>TaUI $d$Ifa$ d$Ifgd-lkd$$If0x)(04 a$qd8$G$If]q^a$gd- d8$Ifd8$1$If:,4<>RTVXZ\^|45Z[avwxúȪznznaULhd5CJPJhNKohNKo5CJPJh5CJOJPJo(hNKoh-5CJPJh-5CJPJhNKoCJPJh-CJPJo(hNKohNKoCJPJhCJ OJPJo(hNKoh5hOJPJh5OJPJ h-5h5CJOJPJo(h>\5CJPJhNKoh>\5CJPJhNKo5CJPJhNKoh^L5CJPJTVXZx dp$If $dp$Ifa$qkd$$If4,0x)h 04 af4Z\^5Lwxn_N@$$7$8$9DIfa$$$7$8$9DIfa$gdd$d$Ifa$gd-$$7$8$9DIfa$gd-$d$a$$dta$okd$$If40x) h 04 af41v<>@BXʿ՜rrri^VKhdh-CJPJh-CJPJhCJ OJPJo(h6P5OJPJ"h6Ph6P5CJOJPJaJo(hd5CJOJPJaJhd5CJPJaJhdhd5CJPJaJhdhd5CJPJhd5CJPJh5CJOJPJh5OJPJo(h5OJPJhdhd5CJPJhd5CJPJhdh5CJPJ>2 $dp$Ifa$kdV $$If4rxO`)` 04 af4yt-$$7$8$9DIfa$>>-d$7$8$9DIfgd-kd" $$If4HrxO`)   04 af4yt-$$7$8$9DIfa$>@Bppp\$$G$IfWDd`a$gd$9$G$If^9a$gd $$G$Ifa$gd$d8a$fkd $$If4Hx)@)04 af4ytnxhjl ".6HXtû|pj`WQWQWQ h[PJh~6h[PJhCJOJPJ hJPJh[h5CJPJh[5CJPJh~6h[CJPJh~6hJPJhCJ OJPJhCJOJPJo(h-hJCJ$PJaJ$hOJPJhdCJOJPJo(hdCJPJhdh-CJPJh-CJPJhdhCJPJhCJOJPJo(l9199d$If]9^9gdJ$dpa$kdz $$If4ֈxO )$ 04 af4yt  99dx$G$If]9^9gdJ d$IfgdJ 99d$G$If]9^9 d$If "kdd $$IfTZִ ")   X   6  H  0    4 aytJT"pd $d8$Ifa$jkd $$IfT4 ))  04 af4ytJT9dhx$If^9gd6P9dhx$If^9gdJ   .fhjl6:<ί΢vkv`vkWhICJPJo(hJCJOJPJo(hI7Th\PJhCJOJPJo(h5OJPJo(h^LhJ5CJPJhJ5CJOJPJo(h5CJOJPJo(hJ5CJPJhS5hJ5CJPJh5CJPJ)jh5CJOJPJUmHnHuhCJOJPJh5CJOJPJo( hJ5PJhJ5CJOJPJo(h5CJOJPJ"X rdP99$9d$x$G$If]9a$gdJ$9x$G$If]9a$gdJ $d$$G$Ifa$}kd$$IfT40*)F     04 af4ytJT9x$If^9gdJ   . =.$9$G$If^9a$kd$$IfT4Sr+ *)G       @     04 af4ytJT d$x$If. 0 2 4 6 9x$If^9gd>\99x$G$If]9^9gdJ99x$G$If]9^9gd6 8 : *!,!H@4%$dp$Ifa$gd6P d$Ifgd+$d`a$kd$$IfT4%r+ *)G          @        04 af4ytJTF N &!(!*!,!.!0!2!B!D!T!V!X!\!^!!!!""" ":">""""""ɾɾڨɛǻ[DZʾ[7\PJ h>\PJ,!.!0!2!D!V!k$qd8$G$If]q^a$gdJ$d8$Ifa$gdJ\kd$$If4x)@)04 af4$dp$Ifa$gd6PV!X!!"<"""0##<$%xxlxx]xd8$1$If d8$IfgdJ d8$If 9r d8$9DH$Iflkde$$If0x)(04 a """"""""## # #.#2#4#p#r#t#####:$<$>$@$D$$$$$$$% %%%ĹĹ鱦鎂sk`k`k`k`hS5hCJPJhCJPJhS5hCJKHOJPJhCJKHOJPJhCJKHOJPJo(h^LhCJPJhS5hICJPJhICJPJhI7ThICJPJhICJPJo(h\5CJPJhNKoh>\5CJPJhOJPJ&&&&x dp$If $dp$Ifa$qkd$$If4,0x)h 04 af4&&&'((,(8(H(kk]]]$$7$8$9DIfa$$d$7$8$9DIfa$gdJd$gd*@*B*X********ööö⨝닂wodYoYdYohCJOJPJo(hdhJCJPJhJCJPJhCJ OJPJo(h6P5OJPJ"h6Ph6P5CJOJPJaJo(h 5CJPJaJhdh 5CJPJaJh 5CJOJPJo(h 5CJPJh5CJOJPJh5OJPJo(h5OJPJh 5CJPJh 5CJOJPJH(I(J(K(T(\(L@222$$7$8$9DIfa$ $dp$Ifa$kd$$If4rxO`)`` 04 af4ytJ\(h(i(>*>0$7$8$9DIfgdJkd$$If4HrxO`)   04 af4ytJ$$7$8$9DIfa$>*@*B******+yyyk $$G$Ifa$gdJ 9$G$If^9 $$G$Ifa$$d8a$fkdQ$$If4Hx)@)04 af4ytnx*+++l+n+++++++++,",$,0,8,J,Z,v,,,,,,,,,,,,,źźŔŔŔŁynynZn&jh+CJOJPJUmHnHuh+CJOJPJo(h+CJPJh+OJPJo(h+CJOJPJ h+PJh[h+5CJPJh+5CJPJh~6h+CJPJh+CJOJPJo(h~6h+PJhCJ OJPJh-h+CJ$PJaJ$hOJPJhCJOJPJo(h CJPJ!++n++5-! d$Ifgd+$dpa$kd$$IfT4ֈx )` $ 04 af4ytT++++++ ,", 99dx$G$If]9^9gd+ 99d$G$If]9^9gd+ d$Ifgd+",$,kd$$IfZִP xp#)G  o X  0   H  0    4 ayt+$,,,,,,,,,,,|m$d8$Ifa$gd+ckd'$$If4 ))  04 af49dp$If^9gd+9x$If^9gd+ ,,,-v--.FocOcccc 9r d8$9DH$Ifgd+ d8$Ifgd+vkd$$If40)    04 af4$qd8$G$If]q^a$gd+,---<-t-v-x-z------. DHJvxz|~DFHJ걺ꤱ걦걦걦꺑ymh+CJKHOJPJh+CJKHOJPJo(h^Lh+CJPJhS5h+CJPJhդ.024:<LN^`źź~x~ribiZRGRGhCJOJPJo(h[CJPJhOJPJ hOJo(hOJPJo( hʴ^>ʴ䴳ʴ(+5Cʴ)+5CʴԱ+䴳ʴ+5Oʴ(+5Cʴ(^9x$9+99x$$Մ99@B24LD8, dp$Ifgd6P d$Ifgd5Cʴ󱷰>5Cʴʴ\5h5CJOJPJo(hOJPJh5OJPJ h2 $dp$Ifa$kd!"$$If4rxO)` 04 af4yt0$7$8$9@¼ⲩ{p{p\Qh pCJOJPJo(&jh pCJOJPJUmHnHuhCJOJPJo(h[CJPJhOJPJo(h[hOJPJo(h pCJOJPJo( h[PJh~6h[PJhCJOJPJ h pPJh[h5CJPJh[5CJPJh~6h[CJPJhCJOJPJo(h~6h pPJhCJ OJPJүԯTV d$If 99dx$G$If]9^9gd p 99d$G$If]9^9gd p d$Ifgd pVXkdK%$$IfTZִ ")   X   6  H  0    4 ayt/TXưȰʰ̰ΰаҰ԰j^ $d8$Ifa$jkd&$$IfT4 ))  04 af4yt/T 9x$If^99x$If^9gd[9x$If^9gd p 8:rڳk_K____ 9r d8$9DH$Ifgd p d8$Ifgd p}kd['$$IfT40)    04 af4yt/T$qd8$G$If]q^a$@ "Hpr~tvx걺ꛒ~sk~s`XhCJPJh^LhCJPJhICJPJhI7ThICJPJhICJPJo(hI7Th\PJh^Lh>\PJhCJOJPJo(h5CJPJ)jh5CJOJPJUmHnHuhCJOJPJh5OJPJo(h5CJOJPJo(h^Lh p5CJPJh p5CJPJhS5h p5CJPJh5CJOJPJo(Z\nprH9$$99x$G$If]9^9gd$9$G$If^9a$kd)$$IfT4Sr *)  3    @     04 af4yt/Trtvx$kd*$$IfT4%r *)   3      @        04 af4yt/T9x$If^9gd>\99x$G$If]9^9gd pxzjlnprtvv`$qd8$G$If]q^a$ $d8$Ifa$\kd+$$If4x)@)04 af4 $dp$Ifa$ d$Ifgd/$d`a$ vHJLN~ҸԸJL¹­햋킖wlwcXPhICJPJhI7ThICJPJhICJPJo(h pCJOJPJo(hI7Th@LNPR^d¼ퟔ팀wwjw]h5CJOJPJo(h/5CJOJPJo(h>\5CJPJhNKoh>\5CJPJhOJPJh pCJOJPJo(h2 $dp$Ifa$kd.$$If4rxO`)`` 04 af4yt/$$7$8$9DIfa$־nrJNhnprtvz|ҵzzzrzjf^Z^Z^Zh!jh!UhhOJPJh CJPJhCJOJPJo(hdh/CJPJh/CJPJhCJ OJPJo(h6P5OJPJh 5CJPJ"h6Ph6P5CJOJPJaJo(h 5CJPJaJhdh 5CJPJaJh5OJPJh 5CJOJPJo(h 5CJPJ#־>-d$7$8$9DIfgd/kdx/$$If4HrxO`)   04 af4yt/$$7$8$9DIfa$LpvgvY $$G$Ifa$gd/9$G$If^9gd/ 9$G$If^9 $$G$Ifa$gd/$d8a$fkd>0$$If4Hx)@)04 af4ytnxprtxz9.)'gd $dpa$gdkd0$$If4/ֈx 9!)I +)04 af4ytz~ $dpa$gdgdhh!jh!U4&P 1h2P. A!7"7#7$7%p T$$If!vh#v#v#vX#v#v#v6#v#vH:V Z0,555X555655H/  / / / /  /  / 44 ayt-$$If!vh#v):V 4 05)/ /  / 44 af4yt-$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 af4$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 af4$$If!vh#vF#v :V 40+,5F5 / /  / 44 af4 $$If!vh#vG#v#v #v@ #v :V 4S0+,5G55 5@ 5 / / / /  44 af4yt$$If!vh#vG#v#v #v@ #v :V 4%0,5G55 5@ 5 / /  44 af4yt$$If!vh#v@):V 405@)44 af4$$If!vh#v(#v:V 05(544 a$$If!vh#v(#v:V 05(544 a$$If!vh#vh#v :V 4,0+,5h5 44 af4$$If!vh#vh#v :V 40+5h5 44 af4$$If!vh#v#v#v#v :V 40++,5555 44 af4yt-$$If!vh#v#v#v#v :V 4H0++5555 44 af4yt-$$If!vh#v@):V 4H05@)44 af4ytnx$$If!vh#v#v#v#v#v$#v :V 40,,,55555$5 44 af4ytS$$If!vh#v#v#vX#v#v#v6#v#vH:V Z0,555X555655H/  / / / /  /  / 44 ytJT$$If!vh#v):V 4 05)/ /  / 44 f4ytJT$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 f4ytJT$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 f4ytJT$$If!vh#vF#v :V 40+,5F5 / /  / 44 f4ytJT $$If!vh#vG#v#v #v@ #v :V 4S0+,5G55 5@ 5 / / / /  44 f4ytJT$$If!vh#vG#v#v #v@ #v :V 4%0,5G55 5@ 5 / /  44 f4ytJT$$If!vh#v@):V 405@)44 af4$$If!vh#v(#v:V 05(544 a$$If!vh#v(#v:V 05(544 a$$If!vh#vh#v :V 4,0+,5h5 44 af4$$If!vh#vh#v :V 40+5h5 44 af4$$If!vh#v#v#v#v :V 40++5555 44 af4ytJ$$If!vh#v#v#v#v :V 4H0++5555 44 af4ytJ$$If!vh#v@):V 4H05@)44 af4ytnx$$If!vh#v#v` #v#v#v$#v :V 40,,,55` 555$5 44 af4ytTT$$If!vh#vG#vo#vX#v#v0#v#v#vH:V Z0,5G5o5X550555H/  / / / /  /  / 44 ayt+$$If!vh#v):V 4 05)/ /  / 44 af4$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 af4$$If!vh#v#v:V 40,55/ /  / 44 af4$$If!vh#vF#v :V 40+,5F5 / /  / 44 af4 $$If!vh#vG#v2#v #v@ #v :V 40+,5G525 5@ 5 / / / /  44 af4yt\ 9r dh9DH$CJKHOJPJQJ@^@@ gQe (Web) dd1$KHOJ.O@. ;ˑjL$a$PJ(B"( ,ge q]q626  9r G$CJaJ&/A&  W[CQKHPK![Content_Types].xmlN0EH-J@%ǎǢ|ș$زULTB l,3;rØJB+$G]7O٭Vhh)1 GHgq]R%kXѹw{uH:}VDp[>UrؘӖ{m/4\ e1n ݳg>4!1A-7bS, #~p &,dZ'FX)jub˓ aٟ}ٓ?^{f9GDr`D ;/K_&-!%\".B-?xtdFTl/ 5g2'<߫s @&WzܟVr}fgX Z|wjk۾xJ{~?(xJ3 kz^BJ tɯUjsȄVxJ|jȫKN1aVkɒ>$"AbG,fxFPd/!E2 f(fKRT#f-y1$8|hWW=yw{zӻ+<˟߿xz{X*G"Eǰܽb;UK8$LU rPI=C,$ EC_jP˳&6[- Q '! :k~ j_F:n-wo4w\@v5jFVW+IfU*mnl+O#W:/PK! ѐ'theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsM 0wooӺ&݈Э5 6?$Q ,.aic21h:qm@RN;d`o7gK(M&$R(.1r'JЊT8V"AȻHu}|$b{P8g/]QAsم(#L[PK-![Content_Types].xmlPK-!֧6 0_rels/.relsPK-!kytheme/theme/themeManager.xmlPK-!ijtheme/theme/theme1.xmlPK-! ѐ' theme/theme/_rels/themeManager.xml.relsPK] [$!   . n<F "%7(*,Jd`<@xvL¼־#&(+/468=@BEIOadjkmquz{~ b 2TZ> " . 6 ,!V!%&&H(\(>*++",$,,F$>4`tPүVXڳNZrxPؼ޼־pz !"$%')*,-.0123579:;<>?ACDFGHJKLMNbcefghilnoprstvwxy|}@ &@H 0(   %* (  bB  S D1#" ?bB  S D1#" ?\B  C D#" ?\B  C D#" ?bB  S D1#" ?\B  C D#" ?\B  C D#" ?bB   S D1#" ? \B   C D#" ?\B   C D#" ?bB   S D1#" ? \B  C D#" ? \B  C D#" ? \B  C D#" ?\B  C D#" ?bB  S D1#" ?bB  S D1#" ?\B  C D#" ?\B  C D#" ?bB   S D1#" ?\B ! C D#" ?\B " C D#" ? bB # S D1#" ?\B $ C D#" ?\B % C D#" ?B S  ?3   ( ) "DE01;ab[$+StxTxTtxTxTt;@V>@mt;@V>@mtxTxTtxTxTt xTxTt xTxTt ;@V>@mt ;@V>@mtxTxTtxTxTt"xTxTt!xTxTt ;@V>@mt#;@V>@mtxTxTtxTxTt%xTxTt$xTxTt;@V>@mt;@V>@mtxTxTtxTxTt./IJ{|GH!"GHvwMN|}   0 1 K L } ~   J K * + P Q  56gh NOij67ijFGlm/0PQ23XY  MN^_cd  ! : ; M N n o !!""####M$O$P$R$S$U$V$X$\$!   &!'!M$\$ssssssssssssss3.I!" :Q}|2 j k u } (  ( JWX3:;D1D w <o0$`Na 3!$$$$$$$$)³յ,\\o(.)$#65A!3"ϱ@BDOPQRTUVWZ\^ \]d([{  5 0 0 00000579;=?ACY[][77;$;$3QHX ?!yZ2!xxS w^'Yx[Ye+^W\O[gah(93t^1g[)NN[ 0D020W/\tRN 1L< 5 j !\$11111 22*2:2J2Z2j2z222222222 33*3:3 i Z'`IZ' Oh+'0   @ L Xdlt|(jDZЮvۧ@fdN(93~1qw)Hƫ Normal.dotm0D020W/쾱11Microsoft Office Word@,@re@Xuk ՜.+,0 X`t|  jA;$   !"#$%&'()*+,-./0123456789:;<=>?@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWXYZ[\]^_`abcdefghijklmnopqrstuvwxyz{|}~Root Entry FData J31Table>WordDocument6 SummaryInformation(DocumentSummaryInformation8CompObjn  FMicrosoft Word 97-2003 MSWordDocWord.Document.89q